Independent profile. Not owned, sponsored or endorsed by First American Home Warranty.

First American Home Warranty Reviews, Complaints & Contacts

First American Home Warranty Corporation, a California company owned by First American Financial Corporation, has sold home warranty contracts since 1984. Its one-year plans pay for repair or replacement of covered home systems and appliances, with a service fee for each request. 239 complaints linked to the First American Home Warranty profile are published on this site (2000-2012). None are from 2023-2026.

REVIEWS & COMPLAINTS239on USAComplaints · none in 2023-2026 · latest 2012
WEBSITEhomewarranty.firstam.com
HEADQUARTERSWest Hills, CA
PROFILE CHECKED
VERIFIED

Contacts

Customer service & general contact

Cancel, billing & returns

Account & login

Official website

Other contacts

Show all 10 contacts

Other contacts (continued)

VERIFIED

Locations

  • Headquarters8511 Fallbrook Ave., Suite 100, West Hills, CA 91304
  • Mailing addressP.O. Box 7248, Santa Rosa, CA 95407
EDITORIAL

Is First American Home Warranty Legitimate?

Legal name
First American Home Warranty Corporation
Founded
1984
Business type
Seller of home warranty (residential service) contracts for home systems and appliances; a California corporation and wholly owned subsidiary of First American Financial Corporation
Website
homewarranty.firstam.comSource: First American Home Warranty home page, checked
Headquarters
West Hills, CASource: First American Home Warranty Contact Us page and Terms of Use, checked
Owned by
First American Financial CorporationSource: California Department of Insurance examination report, Company History, checked

First American Home Warranty Corporation holds a California license as a home protection company. It is a California corporation formed on February 8, 1984 and a wholly owned subsidiary of First American Financial Corporation, which trades on the New York Stock Exchange under the symbol FAF and files annual reports with the SEC. The California Department of Insurance authorized it in California on June 29, 1984 and lists its license status as UNLIMITED-NORMAL, its company type as HOME PROTECTION and its telephone as (800) 992-3400; the department examined the company's finances for 2016 through 2020 and published the report.

Licensing does not settle whether customers are satisfied. The BBB profile shows a B+ rating and accreditation alongside 2,672 complaints over three years and a 2.01 out of 5 customer review average, while Trustpilot shows 4.0 from more than 19,000 reviews. In federal court, customers' class claims over claim handling failed to win class certification (2016, affirmed 2017), and telemarketing suits followed from 2023, one of which ended in a court-approved $700,000 settlement in 2024. Whether a particular claim was handled correctly depends on that customer's contract and facts.

EXTERNAL SOURCE

Independent Sources

BBBComplaints in the last 3 years
1,358 reviews · 2,672 complaints · BBB business grade B+ · average customer rating 2.01 / 5
Figures checked
19,385 reviews · TrustScore 4 / 5
Figures checked
CONSUMER ALLEGATION

Reviews & Complaints on USAComplaints

239 complaints linked to the First American Home Warranty profile are published on this site (2000-2012). None are from 2023-2026.

Show 15 more complaints on this page
EDITORIAL

First American Home Warranty complaints: BBB, Trustpilot and reader reports

BBB. The Better Business Bureau profile for First American Home Warranty (Canoga Park, California) shows a B+ rating and lists the company as a BBB Accredited Business since May 30, 2000. The complaints page reports 2,672 complaints in the last 3 years and 795 in the last 12 months. Customer reviews on BBB average 2.01 out of 5 across 1,358 reviews. BBB's counts change as complaints are filed and closed.

Trustpilot. The company's Trustpilot page is listed under the web address go.fahw.com rather than its main site, homewarranty.firstam.com. It shows a TrustScore of 4.0 from 19,385 reviews. Trustpilot notes that the company has claimed the page, pays for a Trustpilot subscription and invites its customers to leave reviews.

Reader reports on this site. The reports are dated 2000-2012. None are from 2023-2026. Some of these reports name a contractor that the writer says the company sent. The reports date from July 2000 to December 2012, most of them from 2006 to 2009, so they name the company by its former name, First American Home Buyers Protection, or a variant. The subjects raised most often are the quality and charges of the assigned contractor, heating and air-conditioning repairs or replacements, delays, no-shows and repeat service visits, water heater and plumbing failures, claims denied as not covered, and cancellation, renewal and billing disputes.

Had an experience with First American Home Warranty? Tell other people what happened.

Submit a Complaint
EDITORIAL

First American Home Warranty claims, fees, cancellation and disputes: how it works and what to do

A First American home warranty is a one-year service contract: when a covered home system or appliance breaks down from normal wear and tear, the company sends a contractor and pays for the repair or replacement. You pay a set service fee for each request. What is covered, the dollar limits and the cancellation terms are set by your own contract, which differs by state and by plan (homeowner or real estate). Keep your contract and read it before you dispute a decision.

How to request service. Sign in to your online account, choose Request New Service, pick the category and the item, describe the problem and pay the service fee by credit or debit card before submitting. You can also file by phone 24/7 at (800) 992-3400. The company then assigns a prescreened technician, sends you a text or email, and the technician calls you to set an appointment. The FAQ says simple repairs are done on the first visit; if parts must be ordered, more visits follow.

Service fee and waiting period. You pay the service fee every time you open a new request; the amount is in your contract and in your online account under Coverage. The FAQ says many new customers have a 30-day waiting period before they can request service and that there is no limit on the number of requests during the contract.

Contractors. The company sends a technician from its network of independent service providers. Its FAQ answers "Can I choose my own contractor?" with "There's no need to." At least one contract version on its site says the company will not reimburse work done without its prior approval, so call before hiring your own contractor and get any approval in writing.

Repair, replacement or cash. If a covered item cannot be repaired, the FAQ says the company will replace it with a new unit with like functionality, or may offer cash instead, calculated at its negotiated supplier rates, "which may be less than retail." Ice makers, ice crushers and beverage dispensers are fixed only when parts are available. Before accepting cash, ask for the amount and how it was calculated in writing and compare it with local retail prices.

What is not covered. The contract covers only the items it lists. The FAQ names typical extra costs you may face, such as bringing out-of-code systems up to code, structural changes, changes to existing equipment, secondary damage and cosmetic repairs. According to the FAQ, items that were already broken before coverage started are not covered, although some plans bought in a real estate sale cover unknown pre-existing conditions. There is no cap on the total paid per contract term, but some items, including appliances and roof leaks, have dollar limits. The FAQ describes roof leak coverage as an add-on worth up to $1,000, while the home page lists roof leaks among the features of the Premium Plan, so check whether your quote and contract include it.

Cancelling and renewing. The Terms and Conditions page says a contract can be cancelled up to the 30th day after coverage starts for a full refund of the fees paid, provided you have not used the service; after 30 days your contract's cancellation terms apply. If you want the full refund, act before day 30: call Cancellation Support at (800) 327-9292, ext. 7521, write down the date, the name of the person you spoke to and any confirmation number, and ask for written confirmation of the cancellation and refund.

Some contracts require the request in writing; check yours for the address to use (the Mountain States real estate contract on the company's site gives [email protected]) and keep a copy of what you send. That Mountain States contract, for holders outside Wyoming, refunds the unused part of the contract fee less a $50 administrative fee and the cost of any service already provided; your own contract may differ. Plans paid monthly by card renew automatically for another year unless you tell the company in writing at least 30 days before the current term ends.

Emergencies. When the failure of a covered item makes the home uninhabitable, for example with no power, no water or no usable toilet, the FAQ says the company will make all reasonable efforts to start emergency service within 24 hours. Say so clearly when you request service.

If you disagree with a decision. 1. Keep a written record: your online account shows appointment updates, claim status and messages with the company; save them and ask for any denial in writing, with the contract section it relies on. 2. Escalate within the company through the service line or your account messages, stating what you want (repair, replacement, cash amount or refund). 3. If a credit card charge is wrong, dispute it in writing with your card issuer within 60 days of the statement that first showed it, under the Fair Credit Billing Act. Examples are a fee charged twice, a charge after a confirmed cancellation or a refund that never arrived.

This covers billing errors, not disagreements over what the contract covers; for a debit card, your bank's own dispute rules and deadlines apply. 4.

File a complaint with the regulator for your state: in California, the Department of Insurance, (800) 927-4357, which licenses the company. In Texas, the Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation, which has overseen home warranty companies since September 1, 2021. In Arizona, the Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions, which issues the permits home warranty companies need to sell contracts there. In Florida, where contracts are written by the Florida subsidiary, the Department of Financial Services consumer helpline, (877) 693-5236. Elsewhere, your state insurance department or attorney general's consumer protection office. 5. You can also report to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and file with the BBB, which forwards complaints to the company. 6. If none of this works, the arbitration clause in your contract applies, and small claims court remains available for an individual claim.

EDITORIAL

First American Home Warranty lawsuits: telemarketing suits, a 2024 settlement and earlier class actions

The federal cases on this page are described from the courts' own orders and dockets. Claims in a complaint are allegations; only court orders and approved settlements are outcomes.

More on the lawsuitsShow less

Telemarketing calls (Telephone Consumer Protection Act). In Kimble v. First American Home Warranty Corp. and FiveStrata LLC (E.D. Mich., 2:23-cv-10037), the plaintiff alleged that FiveStrata called numbers on the National Do-Not-Call Registry on First American's behalf. Both defendants contested the case, and whether First American was responsible for FiveStrata's calls was never decided. On July 8, 2024 the court granted final approval of a $700,000 class settlement for 21,953 people, without a ruling on liability. Attorney's fees, expenses, administration costs and a $5,000 award to the named plaintiff came out of the fund before the rest was shared among the class members who filed valid claims, 3,295 of them by April 30, 2024.

The settlement is final and the case was dismissed with prejudice. Weingrad v. First American Home Warranty Corporation (E.D. Pa., 2:24-cv-05488), filed in 2024, is a proposed class action alleging calls to numbers on the Do-Not-Call Registry; the claims are unproven allegations. On October 8, 2026, on the parties' joint motion, the court vacated the pending deadlines and temporarily stayed the case. Dobronski v. First American Home Warranty Corporation (E.D. Mich., 2:23-cv-11412), a telemarketing suit, ended with a stipulated dismissal on May 30, 2024.

Earlier class actions over claim handling. In Diaz v. First American Home Buyers Protection Corp. (9th Cir., 11-57239), a warranty holder alleged delayed repairs, substandard contractors and wrongful claim denials. On October 4, 2013 the Ninth Circuit held that the company's unaccepted Rule 68 settlement offer did not end her case and revived her misrepresentation, breach of contract and implied covenant claims. The ruling decided only that those claims could go forward, not whether they were true. In a later consolidated case brought by warranty holders, In re First American Home Buyers Protection Corp. (S.D. Cal., 3:13-cv-01585), the court denied class certification in February 2016. The plaintiffs appealed with permission, and in Carrera v. First American Home Buyers Protection Co. (9th Cir., 16-56038) the Ninth Circuit affirmed on November 16, 2017 in an unpublished memorandum, finding no abuse of discretion in the ruling that individual questions outweighed common ones.

Other case. Adam v. First American Home Warranty Corporation (C.D. Cal., 8:26-cv-00842), filed April 7, 2026, was voluntarily dismissed by the plaintiff on June 9, 2026.

Arbitration and class-action waiver. The website's Terms of Use require disputes about use of the site or the company's services to be resolved by binding individual arbitration and state that "YOU WAIVE YOUR RIGHTS TO LEAD OR PARTICIPATE IN A CLASS ACTION INVOLVING YOUR USE OF OUR SITE OR THE FAHWC SERVICES." Either side may bring an individual case in small claims court instead. Arbitration is run by the American Arbitration Association (AAA) and takes place in Orange County, California or the county where you live, under California law.

The company pays all AAA filing, administration and arbitrator fees for arbitrations it starts and for arbitrations started by others where the claims are worth $75,000 or less, unless an arbitrator finds the claims were brought in bad faith or for an improper purpose. Warranty contracts carry their own arbitration clause: an older Mountain States real estate contract on the company's site sets arbitration in the county where the covered property is located, under AAA consumer rules, with the same $75,000 fee rule. Check the arbitration section of your own contract before filing anywhere other than small claims court.

Parent company disclosure. In its annual report for 2025, First American Financial says it is currently a party to class action lawsuits and that its ordinary-course litigation includes class actions or proposed class actions challenging practices in its home warranty and title insurance businesses.

PUBLIC RECORD

Court & Public Records

Kimble v. First American Home Warranty Corp. and FiveStrata LLC

Settled

U.S. District Court, E.D. MichiganFiled Decided Docket 2:23-cv-10037Source ↗

Settled

The court dismissed the case with prejudice.

Case details: Kimble v. First American Home Warranty Corp. and FiveStrata LLCShow less

Class action brought by an individual plaintiff under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act, alleging that FiveStrata called numbers registered on the National Do-Not-Call Registry on behalf of First American. Both defendants contested the case, including with motions to dismiss, and whether First American was responsible for FiveStrata's calls was one of the open questions; the settlement resolved the case without a ruling on liability. On July 8, 2024 Judge David M. Lawson granted final approval of the settlement: the defendants paid $700,000 into a non-reversionary common fund for a class of 21,953 people, from which attorney's fees (capped at $195,000 under the agreement), litigation expenses, administration costs and a $5,000 incentive award to the named plaintiff were paid before the rest went to class members who filed claims. By April 30, 2024, the deadline for objections, the administrator had received 3,295 valid claims; no class member objected and 51 people opted out.

Weingrad v. First American Home Warranty Corporation

Filed

U.S. District Court, E.D. PennsylvaniaFiled Checked Docket 2:24-cv-05488Source ↗

Filed — no final outcome recorded

Proposed class action filed by an individual plaintiff under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act, alleging telemarketing calls to numbers on the National Do-Not-Call Registry. The claims are allegations; the court has not ruled that they are true. On October 8, 2026 the court granted the parties' joint motion to vacate the pending deadlines and temporarily stay the case.

Dobronski v. First American Home Warranty Corporation

Dismissed

U.S. District Court, E.D. MichiganFiled Decided Docket 2:23-cv-11412Source ↗

Dismissed

Suit filed by an individual plaintiff and classified on the federal docket under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act. On January 24, 2024 the court declined to exercise supplemental jurisdiction over the state-law claims, and on May 30, 2024 it entered a stipulated order dismissing the case, an agreed dismissal rather than a finding against either side.

Diaz v. First American Home Buyers Protection Corp.

Appeal decided

U.S. Court of Appeals, Ninth CircuitDecided Docket 11-57239Source ↗

Appeal decided

The ruling decided only that those claims could go forward; it made no finding on whether they were true.

Case details: Diaz v. First American Home Buyers Protection Corp.Show less

Appeal by a home warranty holder who sued in the Southern District of California (09-cv-0775) on behalf of a proposed class, alleging that the company refused timely repairs, used substandard contractors and wrongly denied claims. In an opinion filed October 4, 2013, the Ninth Circuit held that the company's unaccepted Rule 68 offer of judgment, even one that would have fully satisfied her claims, did not make them moot. It vacated the dismissal of her misrepresentation, breach of contract and implied covenant claims and sent the case back to the trial court.

In re First American Home Buyers Protection Corp. (Carrera et al.)

Filed

U.S. District Court, S.D. CaliforniaDecided Checked Docket 3:13-cv-01585-BAS-JLBSource ↗

Filed — no final outcome recorded

Consolidated putative class action by home warranty holders alleging, among other claims, breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, misrepresentation, concealment and violations of California's Unfair Competition Law over how claims were handled. In February 2016 the court denied the plaintiffs' motion for class certification, along with their motion for sanctions. The plaintiffs appealed under Rule 23(f), and the Ninth Circuit affirmed the denial on November 16, 2017 (see Carrera v. First American Home Buyers Protection Co.).

Adam v. First American Home Warranty Corporation

Dismissed

U.S. District Court, C.D. CaliforniaFiled Decided Docket 8:26-cv-00842Source ↗

Dismissed

Suit filed by an individual plaintiff on April 7, 2026. On June 9, 2026 the plaintiff filed a voluntary dismissal under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41(a)(1), which ended the case without a ruling on the merits.

Carrera et al. v. First American Home Buyers Protection Co.

Appeal decided

U.S. Court of Appeals, Ninth CircuitDecided Docket 16-56038Source ↗

Appeal decided

Individual plaintiffs appealed, with the court's permission under Rule 23(f), the Southern District of California order denying class certification of their fraudulent concealment and Unfair Competition Law claims (district court case 3:13-cv-01585-BAS-JLB). In a memorandum disposition filed November 16, 2017, marked not for publication and not precedent except as Ninth Circuit Rule 36-3 provides, the panel affirmed: the district court did not abuse its discretion in finding that questions common to the class did not predominate over individual ones.

EDITORIAL

Who First American Home Warranty is and who owns it

First American Home Warranty Corporation is a California corporation. The California Department of Insurance's report of examination as of December 31, 2020 (dated January 31, 2022) says it was incorporated on February 8, 1984 and began selling home warranties on March 31, 1984. It was called First American Home Buyers Protection Corporation until the department approved the change to its current name effective November 16, 2016. The report describes it as a wholly owned subsidiary of First American Financial Corporation, a publicly traded company, and says a subsidiary, First American Home Warranty Corporation of Florida, writes the business in Florida.

The company sells home protection contracts for one year, renewable each year at the holder's option and with the company's approval. In 2020 it wrote $376.3 million of direct premiums, 40.6 percent of it in California and 14.2 percent in Texas, and renewals made up about 58 percent of premium revenue. The examination, which covered 2016 through 2020, made one recommendation: that the company review its procedures so that expenses shared with affiliated companies are allocated as their written agreement requires.

More company historyShow less

In its annual report for 2025, First American Financial says its home warranty business "currently operates in 36 states in the United States and the District of Columbia" and that the home warranty and settlement services businesses are subject in some states to regulation by insurance authorities or other regulators. The California Department of Insurance licenses the company as a home protection company. Its headquarters, per its Contact page and Terms of Use, is at 8511 Fallbrook Ave., Suite 100, West Hills, California; the BBB profile lists a post office box in Canoga Park.

On its FAQ page the company says it has more than 40 years of experience and spent more than $174 million on repairs and replacements in 2025, counting invoices paid that year net of service fees. The home warranty company is a separate business line from First American's title insurance and settlement services.

VERIFIED

Company Relationships

  • Owned byFirst American Financial Corporation
  • Affiliated withFirst American Home Warranty Corporation of Florida
  • Formerly known asFirst American Home Buyers Protection Corporation
EDITORIAL

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I request service from First American Home Warranty?

To request service from First American Home Warranty, sign in to your online account, choose Request New Service, pick the item and describe the problem, then pay the service fee by credit or debit card to submit. You can also file by phone 24/7 at (800) 992-3400. The company assigns a technician, notifies you by text or email, and the technician calls you to schedule the visit; you can follow the claim status in your account under Service Requests.

What plans does First American Home Warranty offer for homeowners?

First American Home Warranty's pricing page lists three homeowner plans. The Starter plan covers the plumbing system, electrical and heating systems, dishwasher and refrigerator, garbage disposal, oven and cooktop, and microwave oven. The Essential plan adds clothes washer and dryer, water heater, air conditioning and garage door opener. The Premium plan adds luxury appliances, HVAC tune-ups, roof leaks, garage door systems and additional coverage and enhancements. The page says its plans start at $35 a month and offers a free quote. You also pay a service fee each time you make a new service request; the page says the amount is listed in your contract or shown when you get a quote.

What does a First American home warranty cover?

First American Home Warranty's coverage page groups what it covers into appliances, HVAC, plumbing and home systems such as ceiling fans and garage door openers, plus add-ons such as extra refrigerators, pool and spa equipment and well pumps. It says a home warranty covers appliances and systems of any age as long as they are in working condition, and that a plan can cover a condo, single-family home, mobile home or townhome. The page says to read your contract for specific coverage and limitations.

How do I cancel a First American Home Warranty contract?

Call First American Home Warranty Cancellation Support at (800) 327-9292, ext. 7521. Within 30 days of the coverage start date you get a full refund of the fees paid if you have not used the service. Do it before day 30 if you want the full refund, note the date and any confirmation number, and ask for written confirmation. Some contracts require the request in writing; your contract gives the address (the Mountain States real estate contract on the company's site uses [email protected]), and you should keep a copy. After 30 days, your contract's terms apply; one older Mountain States contract refunds the unused part of the fee less a $50 administrative fee and the cost of service already provided. Monthly card plans renew for another year unless you cancel in writing at least 30 days before the term ends.

What service fee and waiting period does First American Home Warranty charge?

With First American Home Warranty, you pay a service fee each time you open a new service request; the amount is set in your contract and shown in your online account and in your quote. The FAQ says "For many new customers, there is a 30-day waiting period before requesting service", with details in the contract, and that there is no limit on how many requests you can make during the contract term.

Will First American Home Warranty replace an item it cannot repair?

First American Home Warranty's FAQ says a covered item that is beyond repair will be replaced with a brand new unit with like functionality. In some cases it may offer cash instead, based on its negotiated supplier rates, "which may be less than retail." Ice makers, ice crushers and beverage dispensers are repaired or replaced only when parts are available. Ask for any cash offer and its calculation in writing before accepting.

Can I choose my own contractor with First American Home Warranty?

First American Home Warranty's FAQ answers this question with "There's no need to" and says it sends a prescreened technician from its own network of independent service providers. At least one contract version on its site says the company will not reimburse work done without its prior approval, so call the service line before hiring anyone yourself and keep any approval in writing; your own contract states the exact rule.

Who owns First American Home Warranty?

First American Home Warranty Corporation is a wholly owned subsidiary of First American Financial Corporation, a title insurance and settlement services group listed on the New York Stock Exchange (FAF), according to the California Department of Insurance's examination report. In Florida, contracts are written by its subsidiary, First American Home Warranty Corporation of Florida.

What do BBB and Trustpilot show for First American Home Warranty?

The BBB profile for First American Home Warranty shows a B+ rating, accreditation since 2000, 2,672 complaints in the last three years and a 2.01 out of 5 average from 1,358 customer reviews. Trustpilot's page for go.fahw.com shows a TrustScore of 4.0 from 19,385 reviews; the company invites customers to review it there.

Was there a class action settlement involving First American Home Warranty?

In Kimble v. First American Home Warranty Corp. and FiveStrata LLC (E.D. Mich.), the court granted final approval on July 8, 2024 to a $700,000 settlement for a class of 21,953 people. The class is defined as those whose numbers were on the National Do-Not-Call Registry and who were called by FiveStrata on First American's behalf. The defendants had contested the case, and the settlement was approved without a ruling on liability. The settlement is final and the case was dismissed. The earlier class actions over claim handling never proceeded as class cases: class certification was denied in 2016 and the denial was affirmed in 2017.

Where can I complain about a First American Home Warranty claim decision?

Ask First American Home Warranty for the denial in writing with the contract section it relies on, and keep the messages and claim status from your online account. If that does not resolve it, file with your state regulator: in California, the Department of Insurance, which licenses the company ((800) 927-4357 or its online complaint form). In Texas, the Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation. In Arizona, the Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions. In Florida, the Department of Financial Services consumer helpline, (877) 693-5236. Elsewhere, the state insurance department or attorney general.

You can also report to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and file a BBB complaint. A billing error on a credit card, such as a double charge or a missing refund, can be disputed with your card issuer in writing within 60 days of the statement; a disagreement over coverage is not a billing error. Your contract's arbitration clause applies to formal claims, but small claims court remains an option.

CONSUMER ALLEGATION

Related Complaints

Role in the other company’s page

Show 8 more complaintsShow less