Independent profile. Not owned, sponsored or endorsed by American Home Shield.

American Home Shield Reviews, Complaints & Contacts

American Home Shield (AHS) is a Memphis, Tennessee home warranty seller and a subsidiary of Frontdoor, Inc. Its FAQ and sample plan agreement set the rules on service fees, second opinions, cancellation refunds, automatic renewal and mandatory arbitration. Two recent Telephone Consumer Protection Act class actions ended in a judgment for AHS and a voluntary dismissal.

REVIEWS & COMPLAINTS460on USAComplaints · none in 2023-2026 · latest 2013
PHONE(800) 858-1922Customer support
WEBSITEahs.com
HEADQUARTERSMemphis, TN
PROFILE CHECKED
VERIFIED

Contacts

Customer service & general contact

Cancel, billing & returns

Account & login

Official website

Show all 10 contacts

Other contacts

Settlements & legal notices

VERIFIED

Locations

  • Headquarters3400 Players Club Parkway, Suite 300, Memphis, TN 38125
EDITORIAL

Is American Home Shield Legitimate?

Legal name
American Home Shield Corporation
Founded
1971
Business type
Seller of home warranty (service plan) agreements for home systems and appliances, headquartered in Memphis, Tennessee; subsidiary of Frontdoor, Inc.
Website
ahs.comSource: AHS home page, checked
Headquarters
Memphis, TNSource: AHS sample plan agreement, provider information, checked
Owned by
Frontdoor, Inc.Source: Frontdoor Form 10-K for 2025, Exhibit 21 subsidiaries list, checked

American Home Shield says it has sold home warranties since 1971. It is a subsidiary of Frontdoor, Inc., a Nasdaq-listed company (FTDR) that files annual and quarterly reports with the SEC. Frontdoor's 10-K says its home warranty business is regulated in certain states by state insurance regulators and may also be regulated by other state bodies, such as the Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation and the Virginia Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services. The AHS sample plan agreement includes state amendments that change terms for residents of particular states.

Regulation does not settle whether a particular claim was handled correctly. That depends on the plan agreement you signed, its limits and exclusions, and the facts of the breakdown. BBB lists American Home Shield as an accredited business with a B letter grade. The same BBB profile shows 14,663 complaints in the last 3 years and an average customer review score of 1.27 out of 5, and BBB does not count reviews in the grade. The reader complaints on this site center on the same kinds of disputes: denied claims, assigned contractors and delays. Read the coverage limits and exclusions before buying and keep records of every service request.

EXTERNAL SOURCE

Independent Sources

BBBComplaints in the last 3 years
5,780 reviews · 14,663 complaints · BBB business grade B · average customer rating 1.27 / 5
Figures checked
16,352 reviews · TrustScore 3.5 / 5
Figures checked
EDITORIAL

Complaint Themes

Heating, air conditioning or HVAC repair or replacement namedContractor or technician quality or charges discussedDelay, no-show or repeated service calls describedClaim denied or item described as not coveredWater heater, plumbing or drain problem namedCancellation, refund, renewal or billing discussedAppliance (refrigerator, oven, washer, dishwasher, dryer) named

Themes, not a count of complaints.

CONSUMER ALLEGATION

Reviews & Complaints on USAComplaints

460 complaints linked to the American Home Shield profile are published on this site (2000-2013). None are from 2023-2026.

Show 15 more complaints on this page
EDITORIAL

Complaint record: BBB, Trustpilot and reader complaints

BBB. The BBB profile for American Home Shield in Memphis shows a letter grade of B and accreditation since 1997. It lists 14,663 complaints filed in the last 3 years, 4,357 of them in the last 12 months, and an average customer review score of 1.27 out of 5 from 5,780 reviews. BBB says customer reviews are not used in its letter grade.

Trustpilot. The ahs.com page shows a TrustScore of 3.5 from 16,352 reviews. The company has claimed the profile, and Trustpilot does not fact-check reviews.

Reader complaints on this site. The reports are dated 2000-2013. None are from 2023-2026. They are unverified accounts by their authors and were posted mostly between 2000 and 2013, so they describe older plan terms; for the current rules, read the plan agreement you received. The most common topics are listed under Complaint Themes: heating and air conditioning repairs, contractor quality and charges, delays and repeat visits, denied claims, water heaters and plumbing, cancellation and billing, and appliances.

Had an experience with American Home Shield? Tell other people what happened.

Submit a Complaint
EDITORIAL

American Home Shield claims, cancellation, renewal and disputes: what the company's own terms say

An American Home Shield (AHS) plan is a service contract: AHS arranges and pays for the repair or replacement of listed home systems and appliances, subject to the plan's coverage limits, service fees and exclusions. The points on this page come from the AHS FAQs page and the sample home warranty plan agreement linked from it. The agreement you received controls: section numbers and deadlines differ by plan, state and agreement version, so find the matching section in your own agreement before you rely on a deadline.

Request service. The FAQ lists three routes: MyAccount online at any hour, the AHS app, or by phone at (877) 730-4187. Homeowner plan coverage begins 30 days after sign-up; real estate plans start right away with no waiting period. The agreement requires you to file the request during the plan term, and if AHS asks for information to evaluate a request, you must provide it within 30 days or the request is cancelled.

How a request is approved. AHS approves a request when three conditions are met: the item is covered by your plan, the failure is a covered breakdown, and no limitation or exclusion applies. Each covered item also has a dollar limit stated in the plan. Charges for items that are not covered are yours.

Service fee and timing. You pay a non-refundable service fee of $100 or $125, chosen when you buy the plan, each time you place a service request. The agreement states that the fee is not refunded even if the breakdown turns out not to be covered. AHS says it cannot guarantee that a request will be completed within a set time, citing contractor scheduling, parts supply and the complexity of the repair.

If you are told a breakdown is not covered: second opinion. Section 9.G of the sample agreement gives you the right to request a second opinion within seven (7) days from the date you were told of the coverage decision. You pay another service fee when you ask; AHS refunds that fee if it determines that the second opinion differs from the original diagnosis and the breakdown is covered. Write down the date you were told and keep the contractor's diagnosis and your service request number.

Contractor. In most cases you cannot choose your own repair Pro: AHS assigns an independent contractor from its network, and repairs may only be done by that contractor unless AHS approves Outside Authorization. If a covered repair fails within 30 days of completion, the 30-day Workmanship Guarantee covers a return visit at no extra cost. If an item cannot be repaired, AHS replaces it or, in some cases, pays cash instead. Under section 9.H, a cash-in-lieu payment you agree to is based on what AHS would have paid its own contractor. The agreement says that amount will likely be less than the retail cost in your area to repair or replace the item, and in some situations AHS may require you to accept cash instead of a repair or replacement.

Cancel or change a plan. You can cancel at any time by phone. To cancel, call (855) 822-7419; to pause or transfer a plan first, call (844) 300-5270. Under section 15.D.1, if you cancel within the first 30 days and have not filed a service request, you get a full refund with no administrative fee. Under that section, if you have filed one, the refund is reduced by the cost of the service AHS provided. After 30 days the FAQ describes a prorated refund minus an administrative fee of up to one month's payment (where permitted by law) and any service or claim costs. The agreement adds 10% per month to any refund not paid within forty-five (45) days after cancellation; some states set a shorter period.

Renewal. The FAQ says a plan renews automatically only if automatic payments are set up, and that AHS sends a renewal notice and next year's agreement 30 days before renewal; without automatic payments it contacts you to renew manually. Section 14 of the sample agreement says AHS gives notice of any change to the plan price before the renewal date. The agreement also says you can stop renewal by telling AHS at least three (3) days before the renewal date; otherwise the payment method on file is charged. Check the renewal notice for the new price.

If you disagree with a decision. First ask AHS to review the decision, quoting your service request number and the plan section you rely on, and use the second-opinion right if it applies. Section 16.B of the sample agreement, titled "MANDATORY ARBITRATION; CLASS ACTION WAIVER", sends disputes to binding individual arbitration before JAMS under its Streamlined Arbitration Rules instead of court, and waives class actions. Before starting arbitration you must send a written, signed Notice of Dispute describing the claim and the relief you want (to [email protected]), and no arbitration can begin until AHS has had 30 days to evaluate and respond. AHS reimburses filing, administration and arbitrator fees for claims totaling less than $10,000 unless the arbitrator finds the claims frivolous. State amendments change these terms; in Oklahoma, for example, the arbitration outcome is not binding on either side.

Where else to turn. If you were charged after cancelling or billed for a renewal you did not agree to, dispute the charge with your credit card issuer. Under the Fair Credit Billing Act a written billing-error dispute must reach the issuer within 60 days after the first statement showing the charge. For a debit card or bank payment, contact your bank right away. You can also file a complaint with BBB, report the problem to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov, and contact your state attorney general's consumer protection office.

Home warranty companies are licensed in many states: Frontdoor's 10-K says state insurance regulators oversee its home warranty business in certain states. Other bodies such as the Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation and the Virginia Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services may also regulate it. In California, the Department of Insurance licenses home protection companies; if a company denies your appeal, you can call it at (800) 927-4357 or file an online Request for Assistance. In Texas, complaints go to the Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation through its online complaint system (help line (800) 803-9202). Keep service request numbers, dates, photos, the contractor's written diagnosis and invoices.

EDITORIAL

Court record: federal class actions involving American Home Shield

The three federal class actions on this page are described in full in the court case list on this page. None of these cases was about how AHS decides repair claims.

More on the lawsuitsShow less
  • Van Elzen (E.D. Wis., 2024): marketing texts to a number on the National Do Not Call Registry; the court granted summary judgment for AHS on April 21, 2026.
  • Johnson (W.D. Tenn., transferred from E.D. Va.): another Telephone Consumer Protection Act case; the named plaintiffs' claims were dismissed with prejudice by stipulation on December 23, 2025, with no settlement terms stated.
  • Abney (N.D. Ala., 2009): payments to real estate brokers under the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act; AHS denied the allegations, and the court gave final approval to a settlement on December 8, 2011.

If you receive unwanted sales calls or texts. Reply STOP to a marketing text, ask the company to put your number on its internal do-not-call list, register your number on the National Do Not Call Registry at donotcall.gov, and report unwanted sales calls to the FTC on the same site.

PUBLIC RECORD

Court & Public Records

Van Elzen v. American Home Shield Corporation

Judgment

U.S. District Court, E.D. WisconsinFiled Decided Docket 1:24-cv-01206Source ↗

Judgment entered

Putative class action under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act alleging that AHS sent four marketing text messages to a number on the National Do Not Call Registry. AHS said it had the plaintiff's express consent. On April 21, 2026 the court granted AHS's motion for summary judgment and directed entry of judgment for AHS. The court left the consent dispute unresolved and decided the case on a different ground: AHS had shown it kept reasonable practices and procedures to prevent Do Not Call violations, so it was not liable even assuming a text was sent in error.

Johnson v. American Home Shield Corporation

Dismissed

U.S. District Court, W.D. TennesseeFiled Decided Docket 2:25-cv-02347Source ↗

Dismissed

Putative class action under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act. It was filed on December 20, 2024 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia (case 1:24-cv-02339) and transferred to the Western District of Tennessee, where it was docketed on March 27, 2025. On December 23, 2025 the parties filed a stipulation dismissing the named plaintiffs' claims with prejudice, each side bearing its own costs and fees, and dismissing the putative class claims without prejudice; judgment was entered the same day. The dismissal papers do not state any settlement terms.

Abney v. American Home Shield

Settled

U.S. District Court, N.D. AlabamaFiled Decided Docket 2:09-cv-01018Source ↗

Settled

The case concerned broker compensation, not consumer claim denials.

Case details: Abney v. American Home ShieldShow less

Nationwide class action in the Northern District of Alabama alleging that the way AHS paid real estate brokers for selling and marketing its home warranties violated the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA). Judge R. David Proctor issued a Final Approval Order on December 8, 2011. According to AHS's announcement of the settlement, AHS vigorously denied the allegations and settled because of the potential cost of defending the case; the judge found its revised broker compensation practices appropriate under RESPA, and brokers and agents were released from past liability for compensation received from AHS. AHS calls its current broker compensation program ProConnect.

EDITORIAL

Who American Home Shield is and who owns it

Entity. American Home Shield Corporation is a Delaware corporation and a subsidiary of Frontdoor, Inc., which lists it in Exhibit 21 to its Form 10-K for 2025 together with state companies such as American Home Shield of California, Florida, Texas and Virginia. In some states one of these state companies, not the Delaware parent, is the provider named in the plan agreement (for example, American Home Shield of Oklahoma, Inc. for homes in Oklahoma). The plan agreement gives the provider's address as 3400 Players Club Parkway, Suite 300, Memphis, Tennessee 38125, the same street address Frontdoor uses for its head office.

Parent and scale. Frontdoor, Inc. (Nasdaq: FTDR) says in its 2025 Form 10-K that it operates under the American Home Shield, HSA, OneGuard, Landmark and 2-10 HBW brands. Frontdoor says it had approximately 2.1 million active home warranties across all brands as of December 31, 2025. Frontdoor also says it handles approximately 3.8 million home warranty service requests a year through a network of approximately 17,000 independent contractor firms. These figures cover all brands combined, not American Home Shield alone.

More company historyShow less

History. AHS says it invented the home warranty industry in 1971 and has nearly 2 million members; both are company statements.

What a plan is. A home warranty is a service contract, not insurance: AHS arranges and pays for the repair or replacement of covered home systems and appliances that break down from normal wear and tear, and the member pays a service fee for each request. Homeowners insurance, by contrast, covers sudden damage such as fire or theft. A homeowner plan has a 30-day waiting period before coverage starts; real estate plans bought with a home sale start right away.

VERIFIED

Company Relationships

EDITORIAL

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I request service from American Home Shield?

Submit a request online in MyAccount at any hour, in the AHS app, or by phone at (877) 730-4187. Homeowner plans start covering breakdowns 30 days after sign-up; real estate plans start right away. You pay the service fee you chose with the plan, $100 or $125, for each request, and it is not refunded if the item turns out not to be covered.

How much does an American Home Shield plan cost?

AHS says the price depends on the level of coverage, the service fee you select, and the size and location of the home. You pay a monthly plan price, and each time you place a service request for in-person repairs you pay the service fee you chose when you signed up (for example $100 or $125 plus sales tax where applicable). AHS says a higher service fee results in a lower monthly cost, and that its rates start at $29.99 per month.

What plans does American Home Shield offer for homeowners?

AHS lists three homeowner plans. ShieldSilver covers parts of 20 major systems, with up to $5,000 per heating and AC system and up to $1,000 per water heater. ShieldGold covers parts of 27 systems and appliances, adding kitchen and laundry appliances at up to $2,000 per appliance. ShieldPlatinum covers 29 items, with up to $4,000 per appliance, $2,000 per water heater, $1,000 for roof leak repairs and $2,000 per line for exterior lines. AHS also offers real estate plans, and add-ons such as pool and spa equipment, septic, well pump and specialty refrigerators. AHS says plans are subject to change; the plan agreement has the limits, service fees and exclusions.

Is American Home Shield home insurance?

AHS describes a home warranty as an annual, renewable service contract that complements homeowners insurance. On its own site it says homeowners insurance covers what might happen to a home, like damage from fires, theft or storms, while a home warranty covers system and appliance breakdowns due to normal wear and tear.

How do I cancel an American Home Shield plan?

Call AHS at (855) 822-7419; you can cancel at any time. If you would rather pause, transfer or downgrade the plan, AHS points you to (844) 300-5270. Cancel within the first 30 days and you get your plan fees back minus the cost of any service AHS provided (a full refund if you filed no service request). After 30 days you get a prorated refund minus an administrative fee of up to one month's payment, where state law allows it, and any service or claim costs. Ask for a cancellation confirmation number, and check your next card or bank statement; if you are still charged on a credit card, send a written billing-error dispute to the card issuer within 60 days after the first statement showing the charge.

How does American Home Shield decide whether a repair is covered?

AHS approves a request when three conditions are met: the item is covered by your plan, the failure is a covered breakdown, and no limitation or exclusion applies. Each covered item also has a dollar limit in the plan, and you pay for anything that is not covered. If you are told a breakdown is not covered, section 9.G of the sample agreement lets you request a second opinion within seven days of that decision. You pay another service fee, which AHS refunds if the second opinion differs and the breakdown is covered. Check the second-opinion section of your own agreement, because the deadline can differ by state and plan.

Can I choose my own contractor with American Home Shield?

In most cases American Home Shield does not let you choose your own contractor. AHS assigns an independent repair Pro from its network who handles your type of problem, and repairs may only be done by that assigned Pro. In limited situations AHS may let you use your own contractor through what it calls Outside Authorization; get that approval from AHS before any work starts. If an AHS repair fails within 30 days, its Workmanship Guarantee covers a return visit at no extra cost.

Will my American Home Shield plan renew automatically?

Your American Home Shield plan renews automatically if you have automatic payments set up. AHS says it notifies you 30 days before the renewal and sends next year's plan agreement, which shows any new price. Without automatic payments, AHS contacts you 30 days before expiry and you renew manually in MyAccount or by phone. To stop an automatic renewal, tell AHS at least three days before the renewal date, as section 14 of the sample agreement requires; otherwise the payment method on file is charged.

What does the American Home Shield plan agreement say about disputes?

American Home Shield's sample plan agreement, in Section 16.B titled MANDATORY ARBITRATION; CLASS ACTION WAIVER, requires disputes to go to binding individual arbitration before JAMS under its Streamlined Arbitration Rules, not to court or a class action. You must first send a written, signed Notice of Dispute describing the claim and the relief you want to [email protected], and under the sample agreement arbitration cannot start until AHS has had 30 days to evaluate and respond. AHS reimburses filing, administration and arbitrator fees for claims totaling less than $10,000 unless the arbitrator finds them frivolous. State amendments change these terms (in Oklahoma the outcome is not binding), so read the agreement you were given.

Who owns American Home Shield?

Frontdoor, Inc., a Memphis company listed on Nasdaq as FTDR, owns American Home Shield. Its 2025 Form 10-K lists American Home Shield Corporation, a Delaware corporation, among its subsidiaries and says Frontdoor operates under the American Home Shield, HSA, OneGuard, Landmark and 2-10 HBW brands.

Where can I complain about American Home Shield besides the company?

You can file a complaint about American Home Shield with BBB, report the problem to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov, and contact your state attorney general's consumer protection office or the state agency that licenses home warranty companies. In California that is the Department of Insurance ((800) 927-4357, or an online Request for Assistance); in Texas it is the Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation; in Virginia, the Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services. For a credit card charge you did not authorize, such as a renewal after you cancelled, the Fair Credit Billing Act lets you dispute it in writing with the card issuer within 60 days after the first statement that shows it.

What do BBB and Trustpilot show for American Home Shield?

BBB shows American Home Shield with a letter grade of B, 14,663 complaints in the last 3 years and an average customer review score of 1.27 out of 5 from 5,780 reviews. Trustpilot shows a TrustScore of 3.5 from 16,352 reviews.

CONSUMER ALLEGATION

Related Complaints

Role in the other company’s page