Independent profile. Not owned, sponsored or endorsed by National Collectors Mint.
National Collectors Mint Reviews, Complaints & Contacts
National Collector's Mint, Inc., of Purchase, New York, sells privately minted tribute proofs, commemoratives and coins through its website, by phone and by mail. Its Terms send disputes to individual arbitration. In 2013 the company and its president agreed to pay $750,000 to settle FTC charges. 44 complaints linked to the National Collectors Mint profile are published on this site (2004-2026).
Contacts
Customer service & general contact
- Customer service, returns and RMA numbers, Mon-Fri 9 am-6 pm ET(800) 452-4381 22 complaints mention this number
- Customer service email[email protected]
Cancel, billing & returns
- Contact form for questions and returns, order number fieldncmint.com/contact-us ↗
Official website
- Official websitencmint.com ↗
Other contacts
- Morgan Silver Dollars at the official websitencmint.com/morgan-silver-dollars ↗
- VIP sales line for phone and check orders, 9 am-10 pm ET(888) 462-6468 3 complaints mention this number
Locations
- Headquarters2975 Westchester Avenue, Suite 300, Purchase, NY 10577
- Branch officeFMC Processing Center, 32 Railroad Avenue, West Haven, CT 06516
Is National Collectors Mint Legitimate?
- Legal name
- National Collector's Mint, Inc.
- Founded
- 1994
- Business type
- Direct-marketing seller of privately minted coins, tribute proofs, commemoratives and other collectibles, and of government and bullion-type coins, by website, phone and mail, with TV and online advertising
- Website
- ncmint.comSource: Company home page ncmint.com, checked
- Headquarters
- Purchase, NYSource: National Collector's Mint Terms and Conditions and FAQs, checked
Legal entity. The seller named in the company's Terms and Conditions is National Collector's Mint, Inc. The FTC's 2013 court order describes it as a Delaware corporation. BBB lists it as a corporation with a business start date of September 1, 1994 and an incorporation date of November 3, 2004, and shows a BBB file opened on March 1, 2000. The company's About page gives 1994 as its founding year.
Address. 2975 Westchester Avenue, Suite 300, Purchase, NY 10577-2500. This is the address the Terms give for legal notices and the FAQs give for mail orders. Returns go to FMC Processing Center, 32 Railroad Avenue, West Haven, CT 06516.
Website and contact. The official website is ncmint.com; the older address www.nationalcollectorsmint.com forwards to it. Customer service is at (800) 452-4381 (Monday to Friday, 9 AM to 6 PM ET), [email protected] and the contact form at ncmint.com/contact-us.
Affiliation. The company states that it is not affiliated with, endorsed or licensed by the U.S. Government or the U.S. Mint. It is not BBB accredited, and its Trustpilot page is unclaimed.
Independent Sources
Reviews & Complaints on USAComplaints
44 complaints linked to the National Collectors Mint profile are published on this site (2004-2026). 1 is from 2023-2026.
- Aggressive Sales Tactics and Allegedly Inflated Coin Prices
- Paid $82.00 for 2012 Gold Buffalo Coins, Never Received Order
- Bought Two-Piece Lincoln Memorial Set, Received Only One Coin
- $50 Buffalo Coin Sold as 24 Karat Is Gold Plated
- Ordered 1929 Indian Head Coin Still Not Received
Show 15 more complaints on this page
- Buffalo Tribute Coins Are Gold-Clad Bronze Stamped Copy
- Charged $144.95 Instead of $14.95 for One Coin Order
- Tried to Order Buffalo Coin, No Order Number, Run Around
- Buffalo Coin Contains Only 14 mg of Gold, Worth $0.51
- Misled by Special Deal on Gold Coins Costing $449
- Bought Five 5th Anniversary WTC Coins for $180.90, Worthless
- TV Ad Said Coins Used Twin Towers Metal, Want Refund
- Never Received Buffalo Coin but Billed $109.90 for Another
- Endless Sales Call, Extra Coins Arrived and $76.00 Was Taken
- Two Gold Coated Buffalo Nickels Arrived Brassy, Refund Missing
- Returned Buffalo Gold Piece but Account Kept Being Debited
- Silver Dollar Order Price Rose from $617 to $799 Unapproved
- Ordered 10.00 Coin but Billed 44.84, No Customer Support
- Three Morgan Dollars Had Paint, Four Calls Unreturned
- Charged Over $300 for Two Coins, Phone Line Always Busy
Complaint record: this site, BBB and Trustpilot
The reports are dated 2004-2026. The linked posts were published on this site between 2004 and 2012, plus one from 2026; they are individual accounts from people who describe ordering after TV advertising, mailers or the website. Topics complainants raise include: the advertised silver or gold content and legal status of commemorative and tribute coins (including 9/11 coins). They also raise charges for items or amounts they say they did not order; orders they say never arrived or were charged twice. Others raise difficulty reaching customer service by phone or email, and refunds or returns. Several of the same themes, such as charges for items consumers did not order and returns that were harder than promised, also appear as allegations in the FTC's 2013 complaint described on this page.
BBB. The BBB profile for National Collector's Mint, Inc. in Purchase, NY gives the business an A+ rating and shows it is not BBB accredited. It lists 21 complaints in the last 3 years, 3 of them in the last 12 months, and a customer review average of 4.18 out of 5 stars from 153 reviews. BBB's letter rating is based on its own criteria, such as complaint history and how the business responds, not on customer reviews.
Trustpilot. The Trustpilot page for www.ncmint.com is an unclaimed profile with no reviews.
Filing a complaint elsewhere. You can file a complaint with BBB at bbb.org; BBB forwards it to the business and asks for a response. Reports to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov go into a database used by law enforcement, and the New York Attorney General, the company's home state, takes consumer complaints at ag.ny.gov or (800) 771-7755.
Had an experience with National Collectors Mint? Tell other people what happened.
Submit a ComplaintHow to return an order, get a refund or dispute a charge
Returns and refunds. The Terms and Conditions page says purchases are protected by a "60-day, solid gold money back guarantee of purchase price": "simply send us your postage paid return within 60 days. We'll issue you a prompt exchange or refund of your purchase price." The FAQs add: returns must be in original condition and securely packaged, any bonus items received with the purchase "MUST be enclosed," the return form must be enclosed and the Merchandise Return Label affixed to the package. The return goes with a copy of the invoice to FMC Processing Center, 32 Railroad Avenue, West Haven, CT 06516, with a note saying whether a refund or an exchange is wanted.
The company suggests insured mail or insured UPS and keeping the shipping receipt as proof of delivery; return postage is paid by the customer. For returns with a total value over $500, call customer service at (800) 452-4381 (Monday to Friday, 9 AM to 6 PM ET) for a Return Merchandise Authorization (RMA) number and write it on the return label; such returns get expedited processing. Those sent without an RMA number "may be delayed in processing." For items damaged in transit, the FAQs say to send the damaged item to the same West Haven address and the company will replace it once it arrives.
Two time limits on the same Terms page. Besides the 60-day guarantee, the Terms say the arbitration agreement takes effect when you accept it, which includes keeping the product "for more than 30 days." A customer who does not accept the Terms "must return the product in its original condition within 30 days after receipt," and on request the company will credit the account in full for the product, shipping and handling and the reasonable cost of the return. The page does not explain how the two periods relate. To keep every option open, send any return within 30 days of receipt, and ask customer service which period applies to your order. Past 60 days, the FAQs offer an exchange, not a refund, if the item is in its original condition.
Cancelling or changing an order. The FAQs and Terms do not describe how to cancel an order before it ships. Call customer service at (800) 452-4381 or use the contact form with your order number as soon as possible, and ask for written confirmation of the cancellation. The FAQs say to allow 10-14 business days (2-3 weeks) for processing and delivery; overnight or 2-day shipping is available at extra cost on credit-card and online orders. A shipping-delays notice linked from the home page mentions carrier delays and supply-chain problems.
Charges you did not expect. Complainants on this site describe charges for items they say they did not order or for amounts above what they expected. Under the federal Unordered Merchandise Statute, goods mailed to you that you never ordered may be kept as a gift, and the sender may not bill you for them. If an unexpected charge is on a credit card, the Fair Credit Billing Act lets you dispute it as a billing error. The FTC says to write to the card issuer at its billing-inquiries address, not the payment address, so that the letter arrives within 60 days after the first statement showing the charge was sent. The issuer must acknowledge the dispute in writing within 30 days and resolve it within 90 days. Keep order confirmations, the invoice, return shipping receipts and any correspondence with the seller.
If the seller does not resolve it. The Terms require disputes to go to individual arbitration, not court, under the American Arbitration Association's (AAA) Commercial Dispute Resolution Procedures and its Supplementary Procedures for Consumer-Related Disputes. First you must send a written Notice of Dispute describing the claim and the relief you want to National Collector's Mint, Inc., 2975 Westchester Ave, Ste 300, Purchase, NY 10577-2500; the company then has 30 days to resolve it before either side may start arbitration.
For a non-frivolous claim up to $25,000, the company says it will pay all arbitration costs and arbitrate through the AAA office in your home state. The Privacy Policy has a separate arbitration clause, with JAMS, for disputes about that policy. You can also report the problem to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov, file a complaint with the New York Attorney General at ag.ny.gov or (800) 771-7755, or with your own state attorney general, and file a complaint with BBB at bbb.org.
Regulator actions: FTC (2013) and New York Attorney General (2004-2005)
FTC, 2013. On January 17, 2013 the FTC announced that National Collector's Mint, Inc. and its president, Avram C. Freedberg, had agreed to pay $750,000 to settle FTC charges; the Commission vote to file the complaint and approve the settlement was 5-0. According to the FTC, its complaint alleged that:
- the company advertised its 9/11 commemoratives as "exclusively authorized" although they were imitations, and did not mark them "COPY" as the Hobby Protection Act requires;
- TV commercials sent buyers to an automated phone ordering system that presented add-on offers consumers could not bypass, often registered orders for extra items consumers had declined, and led to charges for items consumers never ordered;
- total costs, an itemized breakdown and key refund terms were not clearly disclosed;
- returns were not simple and prompt as advertised: consumers had to pay for shipping and insurance up front and, for purchases over $100, obtain a return authorization number from a live operator, conditions not disclosed in advance.
The FTC notes that a complaint is not a finding or ruling that the defendants broke the law. The Stipulated Permanent Injunction and Final Order (S.D.N.Y. 1:13-cv-00345), entered by the court on January 17, 2013, enters judgment for the FTC against both defendants, jointly and severally, for $750,000 in equitable monetary relief, including consumer restitution. The order also records that the defendants neither admit nor deny the allegations. Under the order the defendants are permanently barred from misrepresenting material facts about any product or service. The defendants must clearly disclose, before a customer agrees to pay, the total cost and fees, the refund policy and any material condition on a "Satisfaction Guarantee" or similar promise. The defendants also must not violate the Telemarketing Sales Rule, the Unordered Merchandise Statute or the Hobby Protection Act.
New York Attorney General, 2004-2005. On October 13, 2004, the Associated Press, in a report carried by NBC News, said then-Attorney General Eliot Spitzer had obtained a state court order temporarily halting sales of the company's "Freedom Tower Silver Dollar" while his civil suit in New York State Supreme Court was pending. The Attorney General said the coin, advertised as a legally authorized silver dollar made of nearly pure silver, was not a legally authorized silver dollar and was only silver-plated, and he sought civil penalties, restitution for buyers and clearer disclosures.
A company spokesman did not immediately respond to the reporter. On November 9, 2004, according to an Associated Press item carried by The New York Sun, the Attorney General announced that State Supreme Court Justice Joseph Cannizzaro had ruled that the company engaged in fraud, false advertising and deceptive business practices in selling the coin. The justice also permanently halted those practices. In a statement, the company said it had complied and would continue to comply with all of the court's orders, and noted that the Attorney General had not challenged the origin of the silver and that the court had made no finding on it.
In October 2005 The E-Sylum, a newsletter of the Numismatic Bibliomania Society, quoting ConsumerAffairs.com, reported that Justice Thomas McNamara ordered the company to pay civil penalties of $369,510 and that the company had already refunded more than $2 million to buyers. The same report said the lawsuit showed the piece was a base-metal alloy plated with a very thin layer of silver, and that whether the silver came from Ground Zero was not part of the lawsuit.
Court dockets
Federal court cases in which National Collector's Mint, Inc. is a named defendant:
- FTC v. National Collector's Mint, Inc. and Avram C. Freedberg (S.D.N.Y. 1:13-cv-00345). The FTC filed the complaint on January 15, 2013, and on January 17, 2013 the court entered a stipulated permanent injunction and final order with a $750,000 judgment. The defendants neither admitted nor denied the allegations.
- DeMarco v. National Collector's Mint, Inc. (S.D.N.Y. 7:04-cv-09206). Filed November 19, 2004. A Revised Order and Final Judgment dated March 2, 2006 approved a class settlement under a Stipulation and Agreement of Settlement dated September 19, 2005 as fair, reasonable and adequate. The judgment also dismissed the complaint with prejudice, and awarded class counsel $135,000 in fees and $4,785.73 in expenses, payable by the company.
- Thomas v. National Collector's Mint, Inc. (S.D. Tex. 4:18-cv-00348). Filed February 7, 2018. On December 21, 2018 the court ruled on an unopposed motion concerning StratusCom Corporation's consent to arbitrate, and on December 28, 2018 it entered a memorandum order and a final judgment dismissing the action without prejudice, which is not a ruling on the merits.
Arbitration for new disputes. The company's current Terms and Conditions require individual arbitration and include a class-action waiver: claims may be brought only individually, and an arbitrator may not award class-wide relief. A consumer who wants to bring a claim must first send a written Notice of Dispute and allow the company 30 days to resolve it; the steps are set out in the section on returns, refunds and disputes.
Court & Public Records
Federal Trade Commission v. National Collector's Mint, Inc. and Avram C. Freedberg
JudgmentThe FTC filed the complaint on January 15, 2013. The case was assigned to Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald, and on January 17, 2013 the court entered the Stipulated Permanent Injunction and Final Order, which enters judgment for the FTC against the company and Mr. Freedberg, jointly and severally, for $750,000 in equitable monetary relief, including consumer restitution. The defendants neither admit nor deny the allegations in the complaint. The order also contains permanent conduct rules, described in the regulator section.
DeMarco v. National Collector's Mint, Inc.
SettledA Revised Order and Final Judgment dated March 2, 2006 approves a class settlement and dismisses the complaint with prejudice; class counsel was awarded $135,000 in fees and $4,785.73 in expenses, payable by the company.
Thomas v. National Collector's Mint, Inc.
DismissedOn December 28, 2018 the court entered a memorandum order dismissing the action and a final judgment stating the action is dismissed without prejudice. A dismissal without prejudice is not a ruling on the merits of the claims.
Who National Collector's Mint is and what it sells
Business. National Collector's Mint, Inc. sells coins and collectibles through its website ncmint.com, by phone and by mail, and advertises on TV, in print and by mail. Its About page says it is a coin and collectibles company in Purchase, New York, founded in 1994, that has grown from two people to more than 50. Former U.S. Congressman Barry Goldwater, Jr. and Angela Marie (Bay) Buchanan, the 37th Treasurer of the United States, co-chair its Board of Advisors and appear as company spokespeople. The company says it sells genuine U.S. coins such as Morgan silver dollars and U.S. Mint proof sets, non-circulating legal tender coins struck for foreign governments, and its own tribute proofs. The company also says that it is or has been a licensee of General Motors, Ford, Chrysler and the Ronald Reagan Presidential Foundation.
Not the U.S. Mint. The site's pages carry a notice that the company is an independent, private corporation not affiliated with, endorsed or licensed by the U.S. Government or the U.S. Mint. The notice adds that its tributes to original coins carry the "copy" designation required by federal law (the Hobby Protection Act).
More company historyShow less
What tribute proofs are. The FAQs describe tribute proofs as privately minted recreations of famous, rare coins. In the company's words, they "have no monetary value" but have collectible appeal; most are struck in bronze and then clad in 24-karat gold or .999 silver. Cladding is a surface layer over a base metal, so such a piece contains far less gold or silver than a solid coin of the same size. Before you buy, read the product page for the item's composition, weight and whether it is a tribute copy, a foreign non-circulating legal tender coin or a genuine U.S. coin.
Ordering and payment. Orders can be placed online, through the VIP sales line at (888) 462-6468, or by mail to the Purchase, NY address. The FAQs list Visa, MasterCard, American Express, Discover, Visa or MasterCard debit cards, wire transfers and check-by-telephone; mail orders may be paid by money order or check. Many items carry a per-order limit. Prices of precious-metal items can change, and the site says a representative will tell you of any price change before processing the order. The site footer says orders from Minnesota residents cannot be accepted. The Dividend Dollars program gives one Dividend Dollar per $20 of qualifying purchases, which can pay for up to 50% of a future order; some sale items are excluded.
Management and address. BBB lists Avram C. Freedberg as president and a customer service manager. The FTC's 2013 case named Mr. Freedberg individually and as an officer of the company. The company's address is 2975 Westchester Avenue, Suite 300, Purchase, NY 10577; returns go to a processing center in West Haven, CT. News reports from 2004 and 2005 described the company as based in Port Chester, New York, and many of the complaints on this site, filed between 2004 and 2012, give Port Chester or West Haven addresses.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is National Collectors Mint a scam?
National Collector's Mint, Inc. is a coin and collectibles seller based in Purchase, New York, which its About page says was founded in 1994. In 2013 the FTC announced that the company and its president had agreed to pay $750,000 to settle charges over its 9/11 commemorative coin advertising and charges for items consumers never ordered. The FTC noted that a consent judgment is not an admission that the law was violated. The New York Attorney General took the company to court over its "Freedom Tower Silver Dollar", and in 2005 a New York court ordered civil penalties of $369,510. BBB gives the business an A+ rating and shows it is not BBB accredited. The company states that it is an independent, private corporation not affiliated with the U.S. Government or the U.S. Mint.
Is National Collectors Mint legit?
National Collector's Mint, Inc. is the seller named in the Terms and Conditions at ncmint.com, which give its notice address as 2975 Westchester Ave, Ste 300, Purchase, NY 10577-2500. Its About page says it was founded in 1994 and sells genuine U.S. coins, such as Morgan silver dollars, non-circulating legal tender coins struck under authority of other nations, and its own tribute proofs. Customer service is at (800) 452-4381, Monday through Friday, 9 AM to 6 PM ET, by e-mail at [email protected],, and through the contact form at ncmint.com/contact-us. BBB lists a business start date of September 1, 1994, and the business is not BBB accredited.
Are National Collector's Mint tribute proofs worth anything?
National Collectors Mint's FAQs describe its privately minted tribute proofs this way: "While these privately minted proofs have no monetary value, they do have tremendous collectible appeal." The site lists U.S. coins, such as Morgan silver dollars, and non-circulating legal tender coins in categories separate from its tribute proofs, and states that all tributes to original coins carry the "copy" designation as mandated by federal law. Before buying, check the product page for whether the item is a tribute copy, a legal tender coin or a U.S. coin.
How do I return an order to National Collector's Mint?
To return a National Collectors Mint order, pack the item securely in its original condition with any bonus items that came with it, the return form, a copy of the invoice and a note saying whether you want a refund or an exchange. Put the Merchandise Return Label on the outside, and mail it to FMC Processing Center, 32 Railroad Avenue, West Haven, CT 06516. The company suggests insured mail or insured UPS; keep the shipping receipt. For a return worth more than $500, first call (800) 452-4381 (Monday to Friday, 9 AM to 6 PM ET) for an RMA number and write it on the label. The guarantee allows 60 days for a refund, but send the return as early as you can, ideally within 30 days of receipt, and keep proof of shipment.
What is the 60-day money back guarantee?
The National Collectors Mint Terms say every purchase is covered by a 60-day "solid gold money back guarantee of purchase price": if you are not satisfied, send the item back, postage paid, within 60 days for an exchange or a refund of the purchase price. Shipping charges are not mentioned as refundable under the guarantee. The same Terms page also says that a customer who does not accept the Terms must return the product in original condition within 30 days after receipt. The same Terms page also also says that in that case the company will, on request, credit the product, shipping and handling and the reasonable cost of the return. The page does not explain how the two periods relate, so return within 30 days if you can and confirm with customer service which applies. After 60 days the FAQs offer an exchange only, if the item is in its original condition.
How do I contact National Collector's Mint customer service?
For National Collectors Mint, customer service is at (800) 452-4381, Monday to Friday, 9 AM to 6 PM ET; the site lists extension 2300 for phone orders. Phone and check orders also go through the VIP sales line, (888) 462-6468. You can email [email protected], use the contact form at ncmint.com/contact-us, which asks for your order number, or write to 2975 Westchester Avenue, Suite 300, Purchase, NY 10577. Returns go to a separate address: FMC Processing Center, 32 Railroad Avenue, West Haven, CT 06516.
Can I cancel an order before it ships?
National Collectors Mint's FAQs and Terms do not set out a cancellation procedure. Because orders take 10-14 business days to process and arrive, call customer service at (800) 452-4381 (Monday to Friday, 9 AM to 6 PM ET) or send the contact form at ncmint.com/contact-us with your order number right away, and ask for written confirmation. If the order ships anyway, you can still return it under the 60-day money back guarantee.
What can I do about an unexpected charge from National Collector's Mint?
First contact customer service at (800) 452-4381 or [email protected] with your order number and ask for the charge to be reversed. If it is on a credit card and is not fixed, dispute it as a billing error under the Fair Credit Billing Act. Write to the card issuer at its billing-inquiries address so the letter arrives within 60 days after the first statement showing the charge was sent. The issuer must acknowledge your letter within 30 days and resolve the dispute within 90 days. Goods you never ordered may be kept as a gift under federal law. The FTC's 2013 order with the company, entered without any admission of the allegations, bars violations of the Unordered Merchandise Statute and requires clear disclosure of total costs before payment.
What was the FTC's 2013 case against National Collector's Mint?
The FTC sued National Collector's Mint, Inc. and its president, Avram C. Freedberg, in federal court in Manhattan (S.D.N.Y. 1:13-cv-00345). Its complaint alleged that the company advertised imitation 9/11 commemoratives as "exclusively authorized" without marking them "COPY," charged consumers for items they never ordered through an automated phone ordering system, hid total costs and refund terms, and made returns harder than advertised. The defendants settled without admitting or denying the allegations. The order entered on January 17, 2013 includes a $750,000 judgment for equitable monetary relief, including consumer restitution, and permanent rules on disclosures, telemarketing, unordered merchandise and marking imitation coins.
Did the New York Attorney General act against the company?
For National Collectors Mint, the New York Attorney General sued the company in 2004. According to an Associated Press report carried by NBC News on October 13, 2004, Attorney General Eliot Spitzer obtained a state court order temporarily halting sales of the company's "Freedom Tower Silver Dollar". He said it was advertised as a legally authorized, nearly pure silver dollar but was only silver-plated and not government issued. In November 2004, the Associated Press reported, State Supreme Court Justice Joseph Cannizzaro ruled that the company had engaged in fraud, false advertising and deceptive business practices in selling the coin; the company said it was complying with the court's orders. In October 2005 The E-Sylum numismatic newsletter, quoting ConsumerAffairs.com, reported that New York Supreme Court Justice Thomas McNamara ordered the company to pay $369,510 in civil penalties and that it had already refunded more than $2 million to buyers.
Is National Collector's Mint the U.S. Mint?
National Collectors Mint's own site says National Collector's Mint, Inc. is an independent, private corporation not affiliated with, endorsed or licensed by the U.S. Government or the U.S. Mint, and that its tributes to original coins carry the "copy" designation required by federal law. Its FAQs describe tribute proofs as privately minted pieces with no monetary value. The company also resells genuine U.S. Mint coins and proof sets, so check each product page to see which kind of item you are buying.
What do BBB and Trustpilot show for National Collector's Mint?
BBB gives National Collector's Mint, Inc. of Purchase, NY an A+ rating; the business is not BBB accredited. BBB lists 21 complaints in the last 3 years, 3 of them in the last 12 months, and a customer review average of 4.18 out of 5 from 153 reviews. The company's Trustpilot page, for www.ncmint.com, is unclaimed and has no reviews.
Sources (7)
National Collectors Mint (own site)
- National Collector's Mint About page ncmint.com
- National Collector's Mint FAQs, tribute proofs ncmint.com
- National Collector's Mint Terms and Conditions ncmint.com
Public records
Other
- The New York Sun, Associated Press item, November 10, 2004 web.archive.org
- The E-Sylum, Volume 8, Number 45, October 23, 2005 coinbooks.org