Independent profile. Not owned, sponsored or endorsed by Better Business Bureau (BBB).

Better Business Bureau (BBB) Reviews & Complaints

The Better Business Bureau (BBB) is a network of independent local nonprofit bureaus in the United States and Canada. BBB says it is not a government agency, has no regulatory power and cannot force a business to act on a complaint. Its A+ to F ratings are its opinion, and accreditation is voluntary and paid.

REVIEWS & COMPLAINTS231on USAComplaints · none in 2023-2026 · latest 2014
WEBSITEbbb.org
PROFILE CHECKED

Contacts reported in the sources (not confirmed)

Official website

Reference numbers (not support lines)

VERIFIED

Locations

  • Mailing address4250 North Fairfax Drive, Suite 600, Arlington, VA 22203
EDITORIAL

Company Information

Legal name
International Association of Better Business Bureaus, Inc.
Business type
Nonprofit network of local bureaus (coordinating body: IABBB)
Website
bbb.orgSource: BBB.org home and About page, checked

BBB describes itself as 'a nonprofit organization that helps people find businesses they can trust'. What it offers the public rests on two separate things: a letter rating that every listed business can receive, and accreditation that a business applies and pays for.

How BBB says ratings work. BBB's ratings page calls a rating 'BBB's opinion of how a business is likely to interact with its customers'. It is built from seven elements on a 100-point scale: complaint history, type of business, time in business, transparent business practices, failure to honor commitments to BBB, licensing and advertising issues.

The point table gives up to 40 points for answering complaints, up to 30 for resolving them, up to 15 for complaint volume, up to 5 for resolving complaints without delay and up to 10 for time in business. The other elements can only take points away, with deductions of up to 31 points for failing to address the underlying cause of repeated complaints, up to 5 for a lack of transparency. The deductions also go up to 41 for problems such as the type of business, failure to honor a mediation settlement or arbitration award, missing competency licensing, advertising issues and BBB trademark infringement.

Scores of 97 to 100 earn an A+ and 0 to 59.99 an F grade. NR means no rating, used when there is not enough information or while a file is under review. BBB says it 'is not a grade, and it is not negative.' Customer reviews are not used in the letter grade, and BBB says a rating 'is not a guarantee of a business's reliability or performance.'

Accreditation. BBB's FAQ says accreditation is voluntary and separate from the rating. A business applying must affirm that it meets eight Standards for Trust: build trust, advertise honestly, tell the truth, be transparent, honor promises, be responsive, safeguard privacy and embody integrity. The standards page says 'BBB charges a fee for BBB Accreditation', that fees are based on several factors including the size of the business, and that not all businesses will qualify. The FAQ adds that 'Accreditation dues do not buy a rating, and they do not remove a complaint', that a business can hold an A+ without being accredited, and that BBB can revoke accreditation when a business stops meeting the standards.

The pay-to-play debate. Until late 2010, accredited businesses received extra rating points for their accredited status. After the Connecticut attorney general pressed the issue, BBB dropped those points while calling attacks on its integrity without merit; both sides are quoted in the oversight section. None of the seven elements on BBB's current ratings page is accreditation or payment of dues. Whether a particular rating is fair depends on the local bureau's file for that business, so the business's own BBB profile, which explains the main factors behind its rating, is the place to start.

EXTERNAL SOURCE

Independent Sources

478 reviews · TrustScore 1.6 / 5
Figures checked
CONSUMER ALLEGATION

Reviews & Complaints on USAComplaints

231 complaints linked to the Better Business Bureau (BBB) profile are published on this site (1999-2014). None are from 2023-2026.

Show 15 more complaints on this page
EDITORIAL

Complaints and reviews about BBB: Trustpilot and reports posted here

Trustpilot. Trustpilot has an unclaimed page titled Better Business Bureau for the bbb.org website, with 478 reviews and a TrustScore of 1.6 out of 5; 89 of the reviews were posted in the last 12 months.

Reports posted on this site. The reports are dated 1999-2014. None are from 2023-2026. They date from 1999 to 2014 and name a Better Business Bureau organization: a specific local bureau, BBB in general, or the former Council of Better Business Bureaus. Common topics are accreditation or membership offers, disagreement with a letter grade, disputes over dues and fees, dissatisfaction with BBB mediation or arbitration, and repeated sales calls from a bureau. A complaint about a specific bureau concerns that bureau only, not every BBB.

Had an experience with Better Business Bureau (BBB)? Tell other people what happened.

Submit a Complaint
EDITORIAL

Using BBB: file a complaint, report suspected fraud, or contest a listing

People looking up BBB complaints usually want one of three things: to complain about a business, to dispute a BBB listing or rating as a business owner, or to know what a BBB rating tells you. BBB is not one company with one help desk. Independent local bureaus handle business profiles, complaints, reviews and accreditation in their own areas, so the right contact is the bureau that serves the business involved.

To complain about a business.

  • BBB's File a Complaint page offers five routes: help resolving a problem, sharing an experience as a review without asking for a resolution, alerting others to a possible scheme or imposter, a vehicle warranty dispute, and a problem with a charity. Vehicle warranty and lemon-law disputes go to BBB AUTO LINE, run by the separate BBB National Programs, which handles manufacturer warranty disputes, not problems with dealerships or independent repair shops. Charity complaints go to the BBB Wise Giving Alliance at Give.org.
  • BBB's complaint acceptance guidelines require that you, your authorized representative or your business actually dealt with the business as a customer, and that the complaint gives your full name with either a postal address, or an email address and postal code. Online filing goes through a BBB consumer account, and BBB accepts one complaint per person against the same business in any three-month period. The problem must have arisen within the previous 12 months, although warranties, guarantees or other extenuating circumstances can override that limit. The complaint must not be in litigation or already resolved by a court action, arbitration or settlement, and must not contain abusive language or serious threats.
  • BBB does not accept employer and employee disputes, complaints about government agencies unless the agency sells a commercial service, complaints against private individuals not in business, complaints that seek only criminal penalties or challenge a law, or claims for personal-injury or emotional-distress compensation. In an injury case it can still take up the customer-service side, such as a refund.
  • BBB forwards the complaint to the business and asks for a response. Its FAQ says: 'We do not take sides, and we cannot force a business to act.' Unlike a review, a complaint can affect the business's rating.
  • Before filing, gather the order or account number, dates, receipts, the business's written replies and a short statement of the outcome you want, such as a refund, repair or cancellation.

If BBB cannot resolve it. A BBB complaint does not stop any legal deadline. For a billing error on a credit card, such as an unauthorized charge, a wrong amount or an item that was never delivered, send written notice to the issuer's billing-error address (not the payment address). The notice must go within 60 days after the first statement showing the error was sent, as the Fair Credit Billing Act requires. You can also complain to your state attorney general's consumer protection office, report fraud or deceptive practices to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov, send complaints about banks, lenders, debt collectors and other financial products to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, or use small claims court.

To report suspected fraud. The File a Complaint page links to BBB's online fraud-reporting tool for fake businesses, imposters posing as real companies or government agencies, and anyone trying to trick people out of money or personal information. A bad experience with a real business belongs in a review or complaint instead. BBB has no enforcement power, so also report fraud to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and, where money was lost, to local police.

If a message claims to come from BBB. Impostors send fake BBB complaint notices and make calls in BBB's name. BBB says it will never ask for passwords or for access to your device. Do not click links, open attachments or reply; to check a complaint notice, sign in to your BBB account directly or call your local bureau at the number listed on BBB.org, not one given by the caller. BBB asks people to report impostors through its online fraud-reporting tool.

If you are a business that disputes a listing or rating. BBB's FAQ says each BBB operates independently and to contact yours directly for anything local; the footer's Contact Us link opens the Find Your Local BBB directory. According to the ratings page, a business's BBB profile generally explains the most significant factors that raise or lower its rating. A rating is lowered when a business is not transparent, for example about its products, services, ownership or address, or fails to honor commitments made to BBB, including mediation settlements or arbitration awards. Answering and resolving complaints carries the most points.

Before relying on a rating. BBB itself says a rating is its opinion and 'not a guarantee of a business's reliability or performance'. Read the complaint details and the business's responses on its BBB profile, not just the letter grade.

EDITORIAL

Oversight of BBB: Connecticut attorney general 2010 and bureau expulsions 2013 and 2024

Connecticut Attorney General, 2010. On September 9, 2010 then-Attorney General Richard Blumenthal's office issued a statement that read, in part: 'I remain concerned about the Better Business Bureau's rating system and my office's investigation is continuing. We have reached no conclusions.' It said his office had written the Connecticut BBB the previous month about 'the role of dues in determining ratings' and added: 'BBB ratings should be based exclusively on performance, honesty and responsiveness. Rankings should not be affected by membership in the BBB.'

More on regulatorsShow less

On November 18, 2010 the same office announced that the BBB 'has agreed to his demands that it stop awarding rating points for dues and make other changes to its rating system'. The release quotes Blumenthal: 'Pay-to-play, or its perception, is unacceptable and unconscionable, as the BBB has rightly recognized'. Blumenthal also said, in the same release: 'While I applaud this significant step, I remain troubled by the BBB's rating system. The BBB lacks the resources to verify much information used to rate, rendering its ratings unreliable and suspect.' He also said BBB had 'a long and laudable history of consumer advocacy' and had often worked with his office against fraud. The release is a statement by the attorney general; it is not a court order or a finding in a proceeding.

BBB's side. As reported by NBC Connecticut on November 18, 2010, BBB's national president Stephen Cox said the rating system would no longer give additional points to accredited businesses because of their accredited status. He said BBB did not agree with all of the criticism and called attacks on its integrity without merit, and the Connecticut bureau said it had never altered ratings for dues-paying members.

Expulsion of a local bureau, 2013. An Associated Press report, published by Fox News on March 12, 2013, says the Council of Better Business Bureaus expelled BBB of the Southland (Los Angeles), which lost the right to use the BBB name and trademarks. The report quotes the Council's president and chief executive officer, Carrie A. Hurt, as saying that over more than two years the bureau 'failed to resolve concerns about compliance' with several standards required of BBBs, including those on accreditation, reporting on businesses and handling complaints.

According to the same report, the bureau's chairman, Jerry Dominguez, denied that there were widespread problems and said the chapter had resigned. The bureau also said it had followed a BBB policy of 'only awarding A-plus grades to accredited businesses', which a Council spokeswoman denied, saying no pay-for-play policy existed. The report links the matter to a 2010 ABC television report that the Los Angeles bureau had given favorable grades to fictitious businesses whose membership fees were paid by a blogger.

Expulsion of a bureau, 2024. In a news release dated June 17, 2024, BBB states that the International Association of Better Business Bureaus 'expelled the Better Business Bureau of Canada's Northern Capital Regions and Quebec from the BBB system on June 3, 2024, for not meeting BBB standards'. The release also states that the Eastern Ontario, Quebec and Edmonton, Alberta service areas continue to receive BBB services through other member BBBs. The release does not describe the standards at issue.

Who oversees BBB. BBB is a private nonprofit network, not a licensed or government-supervised body. Bureaus answer to the network's national body, which sets standards for member bureaus and can expel a bureau: the Council of Better Business Bureaus did so in 2013 and its successor, the IABBB, in 2024. State attorneys general can also examine a bureau's practices, as the 2010 Connecticut inquiry shows.

EDITORIAL

Court decisions involving BBB (ratings, a news release, and an employment case)

Three appellate decisions arose from suits against individual local bureaus, not from a proceeding against the whole BBB network, and each court decided a different question:

  • Castle Rock Remodeling v. BBB of Greater St. Louis (Missouri, 2011). The court affirmed dismissal of a libel and tortious-interference suit over a BBB reliability report that gave the plaintiff a C rating and described complaints and advertising concerns. It reasoned that 'the rating itself cannot be proved true or false' and is therefore protected as opinion under the First Amendment.
  • Caribbean Cruise Line v. BBB of Palm Beach County (Florida, 2015). The plaintiff received an F grade and alleged that BBB represented that it grades on sixteen enumerated factors and investigates businesses, without disclosing that grades partly depend on paid accreditation. The appeals court affirmed dismissal of the defamation count but reinstated the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act count and sent it back to the trial court. The appeals court held that, as pleaded, it challenged factual representations rather than BBB's opinions and that a business plaintiff need not be a consumer to sue. The court did not decide whether the allegations were true.
  • Others First v. BBB of Greater St. Louis (Eighth Circuit, 2016). A charity sued over a bureau news release about its vehicle-donation solicitations; summary judgment for the bureau was affirmed. The case concerned a news release, not the rating system.

Read together, the Missouri ruling treats a letter grade itself as protected opinion, while the Florida ruling allows a claim over what a bureau says about how it grades to proceed. Neither decides whether BBB ratings are accurate or fair as a whole.

Blakeley v. The Better Business Bureau, Inc. (W.D. Ky.). This is an employment case, not a ratings, accreditation or consumer-complaint case. A former executive vice president of a local bureau sued in the court's Louisville Division alleges disability discrimination and failure to accommodate under the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Kentucky Civil Rights Act, and retaliation under those laws and Title VII. The case was removed to federal court in January 2025. On October 6, 2026 the court denied the bureau's motion for summary judgment, finding genuine disputes of material fact, and the case is pending and being prepared for trial. The ruling is not a finding of liability, and the claims remain allegations.

PUBLIC RECORD

Court & Public Records

Caribbean Cruise Line, Inc. v. Better Business Bureau of Palm Beach County, Inc.

Appeal decided

Florida District Court of Appeal, Fourth DistrictDecided Docket 4D13-3916, 169 So. 3d 164Source ↗

Appeal decided

The court did not decide whether the allegations were true.

Case details: Caribbean Cruise Line, Inc. v. Better Business Bureau of Palm Beach County, Inc.Show less

The plaintiff received an F grade from the Palm Beach County bureau and sued for defamation and under the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act (FDUTPA). As described in the opinion, it alleged that BBB represented that its grades rest on sixteen enumerated factors and that it investigates the businesses it grades, without telling the public that grades partly depend on whether a business has paid to become accredited. On June 3, 2015 the appeals court affirmed dismissal of the defamation count without discussion, but reversed dismissal of the FDUTPA count and remanded. It held that, as pleaded, the claim challenged factual representations rather than BBB's opinions, so the First Amendment did not bar it, and that a plaintiff need not be a consumer to sue under FDUTPA. A footnote says the parent organization was also part of the underlying suit, but the appeal concerned only the local bureau's motion to dismiss.

Castle Rock Remodeling, LLC v. Better Business Bureau of Greater St. Louis, Inc.

Appeal decided

Missouri Court of Appeals, Eastern DistrictDecided Docket ED96214, 354 S.W.3d 234Source ↗

Appeal decided

A retailer that sells and installs windows and doors sued the bureau for libel or slander and tortious interference with business expectancy over a BBB reliability report that gave it a C rating and also described seventeen consumer complaints, advertising concerns and the expiration of its accreditation. The trial court dismissed the suit, and on November 1, 2011 the appeals court affirmed. It wrote that although one may disagree with BBB's evaluation of the underlying facts, 'the rating itself cannot be proved true or false', and that the rating is therefore protected as opinion under the First Amendment.

Others First, Inc. v. Better Business Bureau of Greater St. Louis, Inc.

Appeal decided

U.S. Court of Appeals, Eighth CircuitDecided Docket 15-2184Source ↗

Appeal decided

A Michigan-based charity sued in June 2014 over an August 2011 bureau news release that expressed concern about its vehicle-donation solicitations in the St. Louis area, asserting injurious falsehood and interference with business expectancy. The district court granted summary judgment to the bureau, and on July 12, 2016 the Eighth Circuit affirmed. The case concerned a news release, not BBB's rating or accreditation system.

Blakeley v. The Better Business Bureau, Inc.

Filed

U.S. District Court, Western District of KentuckyFiled Checked Docket 3:25-cv-00015-RGJSource ↗

Filed — no final outcome recorded

The case concerns employment, not BBB ratings, accreditation or consumer complaints.

Case details: Blakeley v. The Better Business Bureau, Inc.Show less

Pending case. A former executive vice president of business development at the defendant, a local bureau sued in the court's Louisville Division under the name The Better Business Bureau, Inc., alleges disability discrimination and failure to accommodate under the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Kentucky Civil Rights Act, and retaliation under those laws and Title VII, after his employment was terminated on February 26, 2024. The suit began in Jefferson Circuit Court and was removed to federal court on January 7, 2025. On October 6, 2026 the court denied the bureau's motion for summary judgment on all three claims, finding genuine disputes of material fact. That is a pretrial ruling, not a finding of liability. Later in October 2026 the court ruled on motions in limine and juror questionnaires as the case was prepared for trial; the docket shows no verdict, settlement or dismissal.

EDITORIAL

How BBB is organized: local bureaus, IABBB and BBB National Programs

Structure, in BBB's own words. On its About page BBB says independent local BBBs serve communities in the United States and Canada and that the International Association of Better Business Bureaus (IABBB) is 'the network's coordinating organization'; it 'sets shared standards, supports local BBBs, and operates BBB.org'. The Terms of Use say the sites include the websites of the International Association of Better Business Bureaus, Inc., 'separately incorporated Better Business Bureau organizations in the United States and Canada', BBB Foundations and the BBB Institute for Marketplace Trust. The IABBB page on BBB.org gives a contact address of 4250 North Fairfax Drive, Suite 600, Arlington, VA 22203 and says 'IABBB staff work remotely', so the address is a mailing point rather than a walk-in office.

2019 restructuring and BBB National Programs. BBB National Programs says on its FAQ that in 2019 the Council of Better Business Bureaus (CBBB) 'restructured and created two independent non-profit organizations': the IABBB and BBB National Programs. It describes itself as having a shared history with the IABBB but says the two 'are no longer affiliated with one another'. BBB.org's footer still lists BBB National Programs under 'Affiliated Programs', beside the BBB Institute for Marketplace Trust and the BBB Wise Giving Alliance (Give.org); the footer grouping is BBB's own presentation, not a statement of common ownership or control.

More company historyShow less

The Council is therefore the predecessor national body of both organizations, not simply an earlier name of the IABBB. IRS data republished by ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer lists the IABBB, based in Arlington, Virginia, under EIN 83-3454617 with tax exemption issued in January 2020, and lists the Council of Better Business Bureaus separately under EIN 23-7079691 with exemption issued in September 1918. Complaints posted before 2019 that name the Council of Better Business Bureaus concern that predecessor body.

Tax status. ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, citing IRS data, lists the IABBB as a 501(c)(6) organization, the category for business leagues and trade associations, and states that donations to it are not tax deductible. BBB's own pages describe it as a nonprofit.

Funding. BBB's FAQ says 'Dues paid by Accredited Businesses fund our work, which is how we keep our information free for you.'

One brand, many bureaus. Because each local BBB is a separate corporation, a statement, rating decision or lawsuit involving one bureau applies to that bureau and does not automatically speak for the whole network.

VERIFIED

Company Relationships

  • Affiliated withBBB Institute for Marketplace Trust
  • Affiliated withBBB Wise Giving Alliance
  • Affiliated withLocal Better Business Bureaus (separately incorporated)
EDITORIAL

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the Better Business Bureau a government agency?

BBB's FAQ says 'BBB is not a government agency and holds no regulatory power.' It describes itself as a nonprofit organization. Complaints it receives are forwarded to the business, and BBB says it 'cannot force a business to act'. Government enforcement comes from bodies such as your state attorney general, the FTC and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

How do I search for a business or its complaints on BBB.org?

BBB's FAQ says to search for the business on BBB.org, and that its Business Profile shows the rating, accreditation status, customer reviews and complaint history in one place. A complaint filed with BBB becomes part of the business's public profile. The business directory at bbb.org/search accepts the type of business, business name, keywords, phone number, website address or email address, with a separate field for city, state or ZIP code.

What is the Better Business Bureau phone number?

BBB's FAQ points people to the BBB Directory to find their local BBB and says 'Each BBB operates independently, so contact yours directly for anything local.' Contact details are therefore per bureau. The Contacts block lists the Find Your Local BBB directory and BBB's online complaint page.

Is Better Business Bureau a scam?

The Better Business Bureau describes itself as a nonprofit organization whose independent local BBBs serve communities across the United States and Canada, coordinated by the International Association of Better Business Bureaus, which operates BBB.org. BBB's FAQ says it is not a government agency and holds no regulatory power. BBB also warns that dishonest characters pretend to be the BBB to steal information and money, that it will never ask for passwords or information to access your device. BBB also asks people who think they were targeted by a BBB impostor to report it through BBB's online reporting tool and to contact their local BBB to verify suspicious claims. The Connecticut attorney general's office announced in 2010 that BBB agreed to stop awarding rating points for dues.

Is Better Business Bureau legit?

The Better Business Bureau describes itself as helping people find businesses they can trust, with independent local BBBs serving communities across the United States and Canada. The coordinating body, the International Association of Better Business Bureaus, is listed by ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer as a 501(c)(6) organization based in Arlington, Virginia. Because each local BBB handles profiles, complaints, reviews and accreditation in its own area, the right contact is the bureau that serves the business involved, found through the Find Your Local BBB directory on BBB.org.

Who runs the Better Business Bureau?

BBB says independent local BBBs serve their own communities and the International Association of Better Business Bureaus (IABBB) is the network's coordinating organization that sets shared standards, supports local BBBs and operates BBB.org. The Terms of Use describe the local bureaus as 'separately incorporated'. The IABBB page on BBB.org lists a mailing address in Arlington, Virginia and says its staff work remotely, so questions about a specific business or complaint go to the local bureau.

How does BBB calculate an A+ to F rating?

BBB's ratings page says a rating is 'BBB's opinion of how a business is likely to interact with its customers'. The page says it is built from seven elements on a 100-point scale: complaint history, type of business, time in business, transparent business practices, failure to honor commitments to BBB, licensing and advertising issues. Most points come from complaint handling: up to 40 for answering complaints and up to 30 for resolving them. Scores of 97 to 100 are A+ and 0 to 59.99 is F. Customer reviews are not used in the letter grade, and NR means no rating, which BBB says 'is not a grade, and it is not negative.'

Do businesses pay for BBB accreditation, and does that change the rating?

BBB's accreditation standards page states 'BBB charges a fee for BBB Accreditation', that fees 'are based on several factors, including the size of business', and that not all businesses will qualify. BBB's FAQ says accreditation is voluntary and separate from the rating, and that 'Accreditation dues do not buy a rating, and they do not remove a complaint.' A business can hold an A+ without being accredited. Accredited businesses used to receive extra rating points for their status; BBB dropped them in late 2010, and none of the seven elements on BBB's current ratings page is accreditation.

How do I file a complaint with BBB and what happens next?

Start at bbb.org/file-a-complaint and choose the option to get help resolving a problem; the complaint goes to the local bureau that serves the business. BBB's acceptance guidelines require that you dealt with the business as a customer and that you give your full name with a postal address, or an email address and postal code. The problem must have arisen within the previous 12 months, though warranties, guarantees or other extenuating circumstances can override that, and the dispute must not be in litigation or already settled. BBB then sends the complaint to the business and asks for a response. It does not take sides and cannot force the business to act; if the matter stays unresolved, your state attorney general, the FTC or, for a credit card billing error, your card issuer are the next steps.

What is the difference between a BBB complaint and a customer review?

BBB's FAQ says a complaint 'asks us to help resolve a specific dispute' while a review 'records your opinion and your experience', and that complaints can affect a business's rating but reviews do not. It adds that BBB requires a name on a review, monitors IP addresses and rejects paid reviews.

Is BBB National Programs part of the Better Business Bureau?

BBB National Programs' FAQ says it is 'an independent, nonprofit organization with a shared history, but not affiliated with, the International Association of Better Business Bureaus', created when the Council of Better Business Bureaus restructured in 2019. BBB.org's footer still lists BBB National Programs under 'Affiliated Programs'; that grouping is BBB's own presentation, not a statement of common ownership or control. For a consumer, the practical point is that BBB AUTO LINE, which handles vehicle warranty disputes, is run by BBB National Programs, while complaints about other businesses go to the local BBB.

What did the Connecticut attorney general say about BBB ratings in 2010?

On September 9, 2010 the attorney general's office said its investigation of BBB was continuing and that 'We have reached no conclusions', and that ratings should not be affected by membership. On November 18, 2010 it announced that BBB 'has agreed to his demands that it stop awarding rating points for dues and make other changes to its rating system'. The attorney general said in the same release that BBB lacked the resources to verify much of the information it used (his statement of opinion, not a finding). The release also credited BBB with 'a long and laudable history of consumer advocacy'. Neither release is a court order or a finding in a proceeding. For its part, BBB's national president said the system would no longer give extra points to accredited businesses for their status and called attacks on BBB's integrity without merit.

Have courts decided whether BBB ratings are protected opinion?

In Castle Rock Remodeling v. BBB of Greater St. Louis (Mo. Ct. App. E.D., November 1, 2011) the court held that a C rating 'cannot be proved true or false' and is protected as opinion under the First Amendment. In Caribbean Cruise Line v. BBB of Palm Beach County (Fla. 4th DCA, June 3, 2015) the court reinstated a Florida deceptive-practices claim that challenged BBB's statements about how it grades. The court treated them as factual representations rather than opinion, without ruling on whether the allegations were true. Each decision involves one local bureau.