Independent profile — not affiliated with Forty Insurance Associates
Forty Insurance Associates
Forty Insurance Associates, LLC is an independent insurance agency in Altamonte Springs, Florida, formed in 2012 and listed under Florida DFS license L080461. It says it sells homeowners and other personal and commercial coverage through many carriers. As displayed on October 12, 2026, its BBB profile is accredited with an A+ rating and shows 0 complaints and 0 reviews.
Independent Sources
Shown for context — not merged with USAComplaints' own numbers.
Contacts
- Official website (Forty Insurance): https://www.fortyins.com/
- Agency phone (call, text, fax): (407) 910-2452
- Agency e-mail: [email protected]
Locations
| Type | Address |
|---|---|
| Headquarters | 465 Maitland Ave, Suite 18 Altamonte Springs FL 32701 |
Forty Insurance Associates: contact, claims, policy changes and where to complain (checked October 12, 2026)
Forty Insurance Associates is an independent insurance agency in Altamonte Springs, Florida. It sells policies written by insurance carriers; it is not itself the insurer. Its website says it "represents many different reputable insurance carriers in the state of Florida" but the home page does not name them or state claims or cancellation instructions. An older page on the same site (companies.html, footer dated 2017) lists carriers including Citizens, Progressive, Travelers and Universal; that list may not be current, so ask the agency which carrier issued your policy.
- Reach the agency: the website lists "Call/Text/Fax: (407) 910-2452", e-mail [email protected], and 465 Maitland Ave, Suite 18, Altamonte Springs, FL 32701.
- Claims: the agency's pages do not describe a claim procedure. A claim is generally handled by the carrier that issued the policy, so the declarations page and the carrier's own claims contact are the starting point; the agency can be asked which carrier and policy number apply.
- Cancel or change a policy: the agency's website gives no cancellation or policy-change instructions; use the phone or e-mail above and ask for the request to be confirmed in writing.
- Escalate: the Florida Department of Financial Services (DFS) Division of Consumer Services says it can help with insurance concerns "involving companies that issue policies within Florida" and "agents and agencies", including coverage issues, claim disputes, premium issues, policy cancellations, refunds and sales misrepresentations. It asks consumers first to contact the company and allow an opportunity to resolve the issue, then to file through its Consumer Assistance Portal (assistcon.myfloridacfo.gov). The page adds that most issues can be resolved within 30 days. BBB's profile for the agency lists a DFS phone number of (877) 693-5236.
- Older contact details: older pages on fortyins.com (footer dated 2017) still show 1844 W. Fairbanks Ave., Winter Park, FL 32789 and (888) 958-4805; the current home page lists the Altamonte Springs address and (407) 910-2452 above.
The DFS page lists what to gather: the exact company name, the full name of any agent involved, the policy number, the claim number and date of loss, a copy of the declarations page, a description of the concern and supporting documents. It also says the Division cannot give legal advice or compel a refund where no law, rule or policy provision was violated.
Who runs Forty Insurance Associates
The legal entity is Forty Insurance Associates, LLC, a Florida limited liability company (Document Number L12000105126). Sunbiz shows it filed on August 15, 2012 with an effective date of August 17, 2012, status ACTIVE, and an annual report filed each year from 2013 through 2026 (the most recent on January 5, 2026). Sunbiz lists Martha Rodriguez as managing member and Stephen Johnson as authorized member, with a principal address of 465 Maitland Ave, Suite 18, Altamonte Springs, FL 32701. Martha Rodriguez is also the registered agent at that address.
The Florida Department of Financial Services licensee record shows license number L080461 in the name FORTY INSURANCE ASSOCIATES, LLC at the same address, with Martha Rodriguez as agent in charge. The BBB profile lists Martha E. Rodriguez and Stephen Johnson as managing members and describes the business as providing "insurance brokerage services, including homeowners, auto, commercial, and other insurance products."
The agency's website says it specializes in homeowners insurance and also lists renters, seasonal, auto, motorcycle, commercial, umbrella and flood coverage. These are the company's own statements. Its Privacy Policy (last updated August 23, 2024) names Forty Insurance Associates, LLC as the party responsible for processing personal information collected through fortyins.com.
Complaint counts and reviews as displayed on October 12, 2026
Counts below are as displayed on 2026-10-12 and are not combined with any other source.
BBB. BBB profile for Forty Insurance Associates, LLC, Altamonte Springs, FL: BBB Accredited, rating A+. BBB's raw page data gives accredited 2017-03-27, file opened 2013-06-07, business started 2012-09-01 and incorporated 2012-08-15. The Complaints tab shows "This business has 0 complaints" and the Reviews tab shows "This business has 0 reviews". BBB profiles generally cover a three-year period and BBB says it does not verify information provided by third parties.
This site. No approved complaints about this business were found in the usacomplaints.com archive on 2026-10-12, so no complaint themes are shown. A Trustpilot page for fortyins.com was not found on the same date (the URL returned a 404 page). These checks do not establish that no customer has ever had a dispute with the agency.
Is Forty Insurance Associates Legitimate?
Documented facts: Forty Insurance Associates, LLC is an active Florida LLC filed in 2012 (Sunbiz Document Number L12000105126); the Florida Department of Financial Services licensee record lists it under license L080461 at 465 Maitland Ave, Suite 18, Altamonte Springs; and BBB lists it as accredited with an A+ rating and no displayed complaints or reviews as of 2026-10-12. The address and phone number on the agency's current home page match the state licensee record and the BBB profile; older pages on the same website still show a former Winter Park address.
In the sources checked on 2026-10-12, no Florida DFS disciplinary action, court case or press report naming the agency was identified; a CourtListener search on 2026-10-12 for the exact name "Forty Insurance Associates" returned no federal dockets (RECAP) or opinions, and CourtListener does not cover most Florida state-court records, so this is not a complete court search. These findings are limited to the sources checked on that date. A license record confirms authorization to sell insurance; it does not describe the quality of any particular policy, quote or claim outcome, and readers can verify the license themselves on the DFS licensee search.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is Forty Insurance Associates?
Forty Insurance Associates, LLC is a Florida limited liability company (Sunbiz Document Number L12000105126, filed August 15, 2012) that operates as an independent insurance agency at 465 Maitland Ave, Suite 18, Altamonte Springs, FL 32701. Its website says it represents many insurance carriers in Florida.
Is Forty Insurance Associates licensed in Florida?
The Florida Department of Financial Services licensee detail page lists FORTY INSURANCE ASSOCIATES, LLC under license number L080461, with Martha Rodriguez as agent in charge, at 465 Maitland Ave, Suite 18, Altamonte Springs, FL 32701, and shows NPN 16791762. The record was opened on 2026-10-12 and can be re-checked on the DFS licensee search.
What is the phone number and e-mail of Forty Insurance Associates?
The agency's website lists "Call/Text/Fax: (407) 910-2452" and the e-mail [email protected], with the address 465 Maitland Ave, Suite 18, Altamonte Springs, FL 32701.
What does the BBB show for Forty Insurance Associates?
As displayed on 2026-10-12, the BBB profile for Forty Insurance Associates, LLC is BBB Accredited with an A+ rating, and its Complaints and Reviews tabs show 0 complaints and 0 reviews. BBB's underlying page data records accreditation on 2017-03-27 and file opened 2013-06-07 (the page may display dates one day earlier, such as 3/26/2017, depending on time zone).
How do I file an insurance claim if my policy was sold by Forty Insurance Associates?
The agency's website does not describe a claims procedure. Claims are generally made to the insurance carrier that issued the policy; the declarations page names the carrier and the policy number, and the agency (407-910-2452, [email protected]) can be asked which carrier applies.
How do I cancel a policy through Forty Insurance Associates?
The agency's website gives no cancellation instructions. Contact the agency at the phone number or e-mail on its site and ask for written confirmation of the cancellation and of any refund, and check the policy documents for the carrier's own cancellation terms.
Where can I file a complaint about Forty Insurance Associates?
The Florida Department of Financial Services, Division of Consumer Services, says it can assist with concerns about insurance companies and about agents and agencies, and asks consumers to first contact the company and allow it the opportunity to resolve the issue, adding that most issues can be resolved within 30 days. Concerns are submitted through its Consumer Assistance Portal at assistcon.myfloridacfo.gov.
How does Forty Insurance Associates handle personal information?
Its Privacy Policy, last updated August 23, 2024, says Forty Insurance Associates, LLC is responsible for decisions about how personal information collected through fortyins.com is processed, and gives [email protected] as the contact for privacy questions.